Yeah these are indeed getting pretty stale. Within the show they work better though. Remember that this must've been season 2, and I'm hoping for some reboot for season 3, especially after seeing the whole season 2 finale.
I'll stick by my guns on this one. A friend got me into Eric Andre and I don't normally see live comics, but to me he was the best thing since Bill Hicks. I get the hate for Tim and Eric, like "yeah half the shit posted on poeTV's funnier than that show" mentality (still makes me chuckle) but Andre is, in my opinion the funniest man alive. Except for Burress.
I'm optimistic for season 3, as I'm sure Andre knows that he could soon become the black Gallagher ("ooo when's he gonna run into the desk next time?") Season 2's finale was (I hope) a loving Dear John to all of that.