An 'E' for effort. Some brilliance, some lazyness. But more than I'll ever do for a show I love just as much.

why are they all so dumpy looking

These are college students? They all look so old and tired. It seems like maybe 3 or 4 of them were really into this, and the rest and all just wearily outfitted with dumb costumes as a helpless show of support.

There's... there's a lot of desperation in this video. I'll star that.

sometimes people have dreams and sometimes they come out okay.

I... I... I think I want to LARP... DAMN IT!!!

It gets 5 for the unique version of the Pogues alone.

...jesus.

Woof.

I made it about 1:20 in then I just started half-heartedly skipping around till I got my fill.

Stars for the insipidness.
That is no Dr. Girlfriend.

At least it's not anime. Compared to cosplay, this is megafonzie level coolness.

all this work just to piggyback off of somebody else's ideas

A bunch of nerds imitating the henchmen, who were already imitations of nerds in the first place on a show imitating source material for nerds.

That's like 4 generations of creative regurgitation, which is only a couple less than anime.

Mournful LARP.

As expected, the henchmen stole the show

Way to go boys, the designs are so spot on that LARPers basically look as good as the real thing. I fucking love Venture Brothers.