| 73Q Music Videos | Vote On Clips | Submit | Login   |

Help keep poeTV running

And please consider not blocking ads here. They help pay for the server. Pennies at a time. Literally.

Comment count is 16
Kabbage - 2013-04-19

Oh jesus CHRIST.

That guy - 2013-04-19

OH NO Chris Eigeman, Why?!!!!

Meerkat - 2013-04-19

I would totally not watch this.

SolRo - 2013-04-19

Please change Classic TV Clips to Crime, because this is just that.

Billy the Poet - 2013-04-19

This is what happens when you let Pierce Hawthorne in the focus group.

sosage - 2013-04-19

In the first minute we have one guy stealing all the punchlines to a joke that originally had two guys slinging the punchlines at each other.

I've tried watching this pilot so many times and I still can't make it beyond 3 minutes.

memedumpster - 2013-04-19

Okay, I'm going to go make my own Red Dwarf Pilot now. This has happened enough times that we all may as well take a shot at it. Red Dwarf Pilot can be the next big wave of fan films.

themilkshark - 2013-04-19

Thanks to Netflix I realize Red Dwarf is funniest when you're 14.

cognitivedissonance - 2013-04-19


There's that moment when a young man puts aside "Red Dwarf" for "Father Ted". It is then when the boy becomes man-child.

Cena_mark - 2013-04-19

No way. Red Dwarf is still brilliant as ever. I love the show.

Bort - 2013-04-19

I saw an interview with Grant and/or Naylor, and the story, naturally, was that you had a bunch of Hollywood types who didn't get the appeal of the original show, and just assumed you could throw in stock American actors and make a shit-ton of money. But the actors knew it was garbage; the only part of the original American pilot that worked was Kryten, because Robert Llewelyn. And even when Grant and Naylor desperately tried to fix the script, their changes were all but ignored.

Part of the problem, Craig Charles observed, was that America doesn't have the stock types that England does: Rimmer is an aspiring officer and gentleman, Lister is a blue collar rugby fan, and that helps to frame them. In the American versions, Lister was "a handsome guy" and Rimmer was "a less handsome guy". Beyond the stock types is the fact that the writers made no effort to write material that the new actors could pull off. If you know your original "Red Dwarf" you recognize a lot of lines here that appeared in the British version, but just don't work here (like the "beehive hairdos" bit at 8:56 or so, originally from "Waiting for God").

The one thing that hypothetically made sense was redoing Cat as a warrior woman, in that they couldn't replicate British Cat, so they went in another direction. It was a stupid direction, but at least they acknowledged the problem and tried to do something about it.

SolRo - 2013-04-19

I just think most Americans wouldn't see anything funny about an extremely self-absorbed person that only cares about his looks and food and is a cat.

DavidBowiesLuckyTennisBall - 2013-04-19

They go into it in detail on the Red Dwarf V DVD in the special features. Doug Naylor makes the point that there was nothing wrong with the archetypes of class, or with Lister being handsome (he references Friends as being a comedy of beautiful people), but the writing was just so horrible - full of one-liners with no actual plot development or characterisation.

Also; Lister was a rugby fan? Lister was a Zero-G Football fan.


DriverStabby - 2013-04-19

Fuck this garbage.

Hooker - 2013-04-20

You don't understand the point of this site.

Nyms Lives! - 2013-04-20

01:14 "most of the crew was wiped out" *LAFFTRACK*

Shows just how much of a lack of a fuck everyone involved in this gave, down to the editors.

Register or login To Post a Comment

Video content copyright the respective clip/station owners please see hosting site for more information.
Privacy Statement