| 73Q Music Videos | Vote On Clips | Submit | Login   |

Help keep poeTV running


And please consider not blocking ads here. They help pay for the server. Pennies at a time. Literally.



Comment count is 5
Mr. Purple Cat Esq. - 2020-01-11

The true issue with NMS is not whether it has this feature or that features. It is that, though all the bits are well implemented (impressively so imo) the *game design* of everything from the core game loop to the UI is consistently bafflingly bad, as if they were designed by some weird alien who has never played a game before.

I'll give two examples, one big and one small, but this kind of stuff is *everywhere* you look in this game.

Big thing.
The core game loop is basically a roguelike, you get resources and use them to upgrade your shit so you can get more resources more efficiently.. Thats fine, but... there is no threat.. In a roguelike you need some sort of threat or challenge (normally monsters). The threat motivates you to git gud and level up, and most importantly adds a risk/reward mechanic, you could grind up slowly, or, excitingly risk high level mobs for more extravagant loot and more xp.. NMS does not have this, at all, so the game is just 100% grind.. srsly having a roguelike without a threat is having a game without any challenge, its like designing a 3 legged stool with only 2 legs.

Small thing
in NMS you dont click on stuff in the UI, you *hold down* the left-mouse button for a second... why god why?? why would you do this?!?! We have been left-clicking on stuff fine for 50 years. Why would you decide to contravene this incredibly well established convention? Not only that, but it requires more input from the player for the same outcome. Ideally you want the most to happen in the game (or any UI) from the smallest possible input from the player.
I could understand doing the hold down in maybe one place, for like self destruct button, or erase save games (though a confirmation popup would work better) but they do it almost everywhere. Yes, almost, *sometimes* you do just left click normally also, just to make shit even more confusing and inconsistent.

So great looking game, really impressive features, but constant bizarre, baffling, in a bad way, design of everything. Im only giving those two examples so I dont crash poetv with the amount of text, but those bizarre design choices are everywhere.


Mr. Purple Cat Esq. - 2020-01-11

ps. Other nonsensical shit I would have complained about would have included.
* You cant actually fly or roll or land your ship yourself
* You find a new derelict ship, great!! oh wait your old perfectly fine ship has now disappeared into the ether, and now youre stranded with a fucked up derelict ship that cant fly.
* Trade-in your ship to an alien for his ship. Hes gives u nothing for your ship tho, just into the ether it goes.

*I think* since I played the game they got feedback and fixed or improved those things... But it seems like the designers instincts are just constantly utterly wrong. Like the only way they can achieve ok design is to do it utterly wrong 1st, then people complain about it, then they do it again.


Born in the RSR - 2020-01-11

I, for one, enjoyed your text wall.

When the hype-train on this thing got rolling i was deep into Starbound, a game that has been cosistantly updated and improved years and years after I boght it for a meisly 13 euros and that did eveything that NMS did but better and in 2d.


Spike Jonez - 2020-01-11

Accurate.


casualcollapse - 2023-12-25

fuck wonder where IH stole the script for this from


Register or login To Post a Comment







Video content copyright the respective clip/station owners please see hosting site for more information.
Privacy Statement